The slogan about the ‘other world’ that is possible has been around for 25 years, yet today it is more relevant than ever—and further away than ever. The people at the World Social Forum who started it all thought they didn’t need politics to create a new reality. They thought that a dynamic global civil society was enough to improve the world. But the global civil society does not exist, and the project flopped.
Although there was already talk of ‘globalization’ at the end of the nineteenth century, and the West’s exploration of the world had begun five hundred years earlier with the voyages of discovery and colonization, it was only after the Second World War that the plan was conceived to turn that world into a ‘better’ one. At least, so it was said.
The colonies became independent states, the French and British empires disappeared, and the United States of America began to play a dominant role, aided by the institutions created by the victors of the war: the UN, the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank.
There were grand plans, and people spoke of ‘development’ with a number of ideas that have now lost their credibility in the eyes of both progressives and neoliberals.
The ‘new’ nations gathered in Bandung; resolutions on development were adopted at the UN; and a declaration on a ‘new international economic order’ was issued. Willy Brandt wrote two brilliant reports on what was needed to genuinely provide the world’s population with a decent standard of living. In the European Union, a fund was set up to stabilise the prices of raw materials exported by ‘developing countries’. A UN organisation for trade and development was established. Concrete plans were drawn up for ‘social’ development.
It was all to no avail. Analyses of the reasons for the failure have been carried out; let us simply state here that the practice of ‘development work’ was by no means in line with the theory or with the good intentions of many. The colonial mentality had not disappeared at all. Development reached what was termed an ‘impasse’.
This impasse coincided with the onset of the foreign debt crisis, the imposition of ‘structural adjustments,’ and the introduction of neoliberalism. Suddenly, there was no longer a ‘development economy’ but rather a ‘pensée unique’. The economy disappeared from political and democratic debate. The rules were set; from then on, it was within that new framework that ‘poverty’ would be tackled.
Working towards a new world
It was against this backdrop that, around the turn of the century, more and more voices began to call for another world. The new concept of ‘sustainable development’ had already been coined in the 1980s, and attention was suddenly being paid to the role of women and indigenous peoples.
However, alternatives to the economically and socially disastrous neoliberalism failed to materialize. Initially, an explanation could be found in the fall of the Berlin Wall and the disappearance of a socialist or communist alternative. It was clear that ‘real existing socialism’ held little appeal for most people.
There was no shortage of analyses of how capitalism was destroying the world and how the ideology of free trade was repeatedly stripping the poorer countries bare and impoverishing them. The new ‘decolonisation’ and ‘post-development’ that were advocated may well have exposed the many problems, but there was still no alternative.
Meanwhile, there was one country that was indeed developing, industrializing, and growing wealthy on its own terms: China. Its economic success commands admiration, even though there is no trace of those much-vaunted ‘Western values’. Limited democracy and limited freedom. Yet undeniable technological and material progress.
Inability
It is wrong to claim that no work was being done on alternatives to Western capitalism and development thinking. To what extent these are genuine alternatives, however, remains to be seen.
Take the UN’s ‘Sustainable Development Goals’. Viewed objectively, they do indeed envisage a ‘different world’; they apply to both the North and the South and, if fully implemented, would certainly mean a better life for the world’s population. However, little is actually being achieved, as evidenced by the latest report on the subject from 2026. Of the 139 measurable goals, only 15 percent are ‘on track’, whilst a further 15 percent are performing worse than in 2015. Ten percent of the world’s population lives in extreme poverty and 2.3 billion people lack food security.
This can certainly be attributed to a lack of political will. It can also be blamed on an absolute inability to achieve anything better within the current economic and financial framework, in which the distribution of power takes account only of those who already have everything.
One might criticize the UN for being a talking shop that is unable to offer concrete solutions. That is correct to a certain extent, but it must be reiterated here once again that intergovernmental organisations can never be stronger than the states that shape them.
What the UN can do—and does do effectively—is to draw up alternatives on paper. In that respect, the organisation cannot be faulted. Anyone who re-reads the UNDP’s reports from the early 1990s will be struck by their progressive boldness and insight. The UNDP was the first to draw attention to the unsustainable inequality in the world and to speak of ‘human security’ through a global social charter. Civil society could have taken this on board, but it did not really happen.
Local initiatives
In fact, an unimaginable number of initiatives are underway, albeit at a local level. Many social movements have moved away from a global approach. The most fully developed ideas are to be found in what is now referred to as the ‘social and solidarity-based’ economy. These are socio-economic projects that empower people to become self-reliant through collaboration, thereby helping to eradicate poverty and ensure food security. Each and every one of these is a highly useful initiative that can be applied across a wide range of sectors in both production and consumption. These are forms of community-building that do not necessarily have to operate on a limited local scale. In the past, there were already large national and even international cooperatives in the banking and insurance sectors. Moreover, the many local initiatives also collaborate within international organizations.
The sector exists and operates within a given capitalist framework that it cannot change. It must also compete with companies that are not required to take into account the generally high ethical standards applied within the SSE sector.
Finally, there are sectors in which a global production system seems difficult to replace for the time being. Think of our laptops and mobile phones, cars, airplanes, and ships.
Or, to put it another way, the social and solidarity economy can play a particularly useful role at a local level and can be classified amongst the initiatives of the ‘life-improvers’, not those of the ‘world-improvers’. The SSE sector exists in parallel with a destructive capitalist system.
Even when these initiatives are framed in terms of ‘commons’, the limitations remain. The philosophers who sought to give them a global dimension keep coming up against the same barriers. Global commons are nothing more than a global political practice whose feasibility has yet to be proven.
Forward-looking initiatives will inevitably have to look further afield. After all, this is not merely a matter of local self-reliance and well-being but of growing and unsustainable global inequality, with institutions that merely reinforce the power of those who already have far too much of it and who are the cause of local misery. Poverty is not a fact of nature but the result of a political process. The ‘poverty factories’ must be shut down, and action at the local or even national level is not enough to achieve this.
Global initiatives
Neither the World Economic Forum in Davos nor the World Social Forum in Porto Alegre has been able to set out clear guidelines for what a new world order might look like. Both have foundered on good intentions that stand no chance whatsoever given the current balance of power. The debate continues to waver between a focus on nation states and international partnerships, between the nationalization of the economy and the internationalization of the social struggle. Today, new ideas are emerging more from the tech world than from the World Bank or the UN.
It should be clear that no single country, however strong or powerful, is capable of solving the major problems facing all nations—social, economic, and environmental—on its own. Anyone who continues to fixate on nation-states can only do so in terms of power. Perhaps you can solve some problems by imposing your will on others. That is the game currently being played by the US.
Anyone who wants to slow down climate change will have to work together with others. Anyone who wants to stem the flow of migration will have to tackle inequality. Anyone who wants to put a stop to the shift to the right will have to put social and economic rights on the agenda. Anyone who wants to eradicate organized crime will have to harmonize legislation.
With every major disaster in the world, it is clear that there is great potential for solidarity. Think of Gaza, the floods, forest fires, and earthquakes—time and again, people rise to help others. The potential is there, but it is still not being utilised enough to organise people at an international and global level.
There is absolutely no need to choose between local, national, or global action. Action is needed at all these levels, and they can complement and reinforce one another.
National movements can build on the often excellent work already being done globally, both by the UN through its generally strong reports and by civil society through research on IMF and World Bank austerity programmes, international debt, universal social protection, housing policy, and much more. Today, however, this potential is being used far too little.
The only ambitious long-term program currently on the table is that of Thomas Piketty and his colleagues at the World Inequality Lab. The ‘Global Justice Project’ aims for 2100 and contains proposals that are technically perfectly feasible, some of which already exist or have existed in the past and are based on a wealth of statistics and figures.
It is utopian, to be sure, but why shouldn’t it be possible? Planetary habitability, social justice, and a new financial architecture. If these three objectives are achieved, the economic system will automatically have changed to such an extent that it will no longer recognise itself.
That must be the aim. There are people and movements, at all levels, who are prepared to commit themselves to this. They must, however, be willing to organize.














