They arrest Gabriella– they drag her away in the middle of the night.
You remember Gabriella, right? Did you forget about Gabriella?
It’s easy to forget. It’s easy to lose somebody in the soup. Gabriella is the one who was leading the protests in the marketplace square in El Toboso. She was the one with the bullhorn– or with the cupped hands, maybe. It’s easy to forget what year it’s supposed to be. She runs away with everyone else when the soldiers or the police arrive to break everything up, but what does that matter? El Toboso is a small town, a dusty little town. There are like twelve people who live in El Toboso. The soldiers go first to eight of the eleven other people before they get their act together and finally figure out where Gabriella is, and they drag her away in the middle of the night– simple as that.
They bring her down to a dark dungeon near the edge of town. It’s not very impressive, actually. It all used to be a wine-cellar, actually, and it was the only place besides maybe the basement of the Church that might have been able to be any sort of dungeon, and the Priest wasn’t having any of this nonsense in the Church, so here they are. The Inquisition have done the best it can to make it really feel like something. They’ve put curtains over all the windows up near the ceiling, or else bricked them up.
They’ve laid everything out so that when you are sitting in the interrogation room, you can hear the groans from the prison-cells, or the screams from the room where the prisoners are being tortured, which nobody calls the “torture-room”; they simply don’t call it that; they simply don’t say that; they would look at you strange if you ever said something like that.
Gabriella sits on one side of the table. There is a man who sits on the other side of the table. It is the middle of the morning when he talks to her; she has been waiting for hours. She is seated facing the door because the man wants her to try and get up and make a run for it– or at least he wants her to be thinking about it. A few knives of sunshine are slipping in past the edges of those curtains up there, behind Gabriella’s head, and the man keeps adjusting how he is sitting to try and keep his face in the shadows, keep up his mystery or his threatening aura, or maybe just to keep the sharp light out of his eyes.
As he is talking, he is thinking about how maybe he and Gabriella ought to have their places switched, so that the light will be in her eyes instead. It is hundreds and hundreds of years before anyone will invent any sort of electrical lightbulb that he might be able to hang from the ceiling and blast into her face while he is asking her questions, but fuck it, the Inquisition’s got a monster of a budget, fuck it, he’s going to put in a request for one of those as soon as he’s done with this, here. “Who else?” he asks Gabriella, across the table. He’s got both his hands flat down on the surface.
“There’s no one else,” Gabriella answers him, which is bullshit. Obviously, there are other people. There were other people. It was a whole-ass protest in the middle of the marketplace square, during the marching of the prisoners. There were nearly a hundred people chanting, holding signs, and throwing tomatoes. Never mind that it’s still a hundred years or so before the tomatoes brought back from Mexico by the conquistadors will become enough of a food staple here in Spain that people will have plenty to throw, but fuck that– the protestors have a good budget, right?-- they’re all paid protestors, don’t you know that?-- Haven’t you heard that? They’re all being paid for by Iran; they can spring for some throwing tomatoes. “I was the only protestor,” says Gabriella, which is bullshit, and then she adds, “if there even were any protestors,” and then “how are you going to prove that there was ever a protest, or that I was ever there?” she asks, which is bullshit, but she’s really riding the wave, now. She’s feeling defiant, is how she’s feeling– damn. That’s a feeling. Damn. That’s like if a heartbeat could rumble.
“If there is no one else, how did we find you?” asks the man. “We have several of your fellow conspirators in the other room,” he says, which is bullshit. “They’ve already turned against you– they’ve already named your name,” he says, which is bullshit– they’ve got nobody on this– they’ve got nothing. “Here is the question that decides what happens next,” says the man: “Are you the end of the chain, or are there more links after you? You don’t want to name anybody else?-- fine. Easier for us, then. We can just go ahead and say that we’ve found the person we needed.”
He leans back, folds his arms across his chest, and then changes his mind– he reaches up and laces his fingers behind his head instead, like he’s relaxing, like he doesn’t really care so much.
Gabriella tries to imitate him– she doesn’t care either!-- defiance!-- defiance!-- but of course her wrists are chained together, and also they’re chained to the table, so she can’t lean back or any of that; instead, what she does is puts down her elbows onto the table and she props up her chin on her wrists, and she rolls off her eyes towards the left like a bored teenager. They sit this way, both of them, for maybe twenty seconds, and then the door behind the man unlatches and creaks open, and it startles him so much he very nearly falls over backwards, chair and all. He is even more sure, now, that he and Gabriella should be in the opposite places.
The soldier who comes in says that there’s no need for this to continue. They’ve already got everyone else. They can just take her away now and move on to other things. “Ah, well,” says the man. “Well, then,” says the man. He gets up, and he leaves, and as he is leaving, he glances back at Gabriella, still in the chair, and what he says to her is, “I wonder how you will look back later at this moment and these decisions. I wonder what little stories you will tell yourself about what you might have done differently today to change everything that is coming next.”-- and then he goes, and he is gone.
What comes next is that they take her to the room called “The Old Vintages” because they have what they think is a sense of humour, and they torture her. Fuck– it’s ugly in there. All the stories that Gabriella has been telling herself about herself for her whole life, about strength under torture, about maybe it will hurt, but they can’t break me, they’ll never break me, I’ll grit my teeth through the pain, I won’t be like the people who break, I’m not like those people, I’ll be different– fuck all that; she starts screaming out names after maybe three minutes– and one of those minutes is just getting her set up to start.
Here is what they’ve done to her: they’ve put the fingers of her left hand into a device, and they’ve started to bend them backwards, a little bit at a time, with a ratcheting sort of mechanism. It feels like they might as well have just had some man grab her fingers and bend them himself, but maybe he might do it too quickly, or maybe he might not have it in him to do it at all– it’s not so easy to hurt a person. Maybe all the stories he’s told himself about how he can hurt a person, fuck all that. Maybe he can’t do it if he can see her face. Maybe he can’t do it if he can hear her voice. Maybe even if he were blind and deaf, he couldn’t do it. Or maybe it’s just something about it being a machine; your fingers are in the machine, now– it’s bigger than you and me, now. It’s out of anyone’s control, now. It’s not in anybody’s control now.
Gabriella starts spilling before it even really starts to hurt. “Aldonza Gonzalo!” she cries out– it’s the first face that appears behind her eyes. Kenia Nogales! Both of them! They were there!” It hurts, it hurts, but it doesn’t really hurt, not yet. Nothing is broken, not yet, maybe just a little strained, overstretched. It’ll all be sore later if it stops now.
“Isabella de Alejandro was part of it!” she cries out– why is she only naming women and girls? “Immanuel!” she cries out. She can’t remember his last name. Her fingers are bending and bending. “Immanuel!” She thinks about her fingers breaking, now, soon. She thinks about the pain of it, and she’s imagined that kind of pain before, and she’s sure– still, now– that she can face it, but what she’d never thought about thinking about before right this moment, here, today, is that she likes her fingers. She likes how they are. She’s gotten so used to her fingers and her hands and her wrists and her arms after all these years with them. She screams all the names of all the people who were at the protest with her, and then she screams all the other names that she can think of– just people she knows– just people they might believe would be a part of this.
They break her fingers with a sound she didn’t think a body could make– she’s seen fingers break and she’s never heard that– but it sounds different when it’s coming from inside of you, like your heartbeat, or your own voice. They move on to her left elbow; they lock her upper arm into a vice, and they start to twist. Gabriella runs out of names of people she knows and switches to names she’s just heard– “Miguel Cervantes! ¡Alonso Quijana! Phillip! Isabella! Lorenzo de Medici! Rachel Lahey! Asa Sutton!” She runs out of those and starts just making up new names from nowhere.
They let her rest in the dungeon for a few days, at least, before they drag her out with the other prisoners. They wrap up her left arm in splints and bandages, and they put a splint along the ribs of her left side as well, and a bit of cotton to keep in her mouth to soak up any leftover blood from the teeth. After a few teeth, they give her a bright yellow sanbenito to wear, with the flames pointing downwards, which means that she will be strangled into unconsciousness before she is tied to the stake and burned, to reduce her suffering. She has confessed her crimes, and she has confessed the names of all her coconspirators– and she’s confessed the names of pretty much everyone else in the world, while she was at it.
She’s earned herself a little mercy. They give her a pointed cap for her head, and they give her a rope for her neck like a necklace. They give her some chains to keep her together with the other prisoners– “Here,” says the man, and this is how he says it, “let me give you these.”-- and they give her a candle to hold. It drips hot wax into the palm of her right hand as she shuffles out of the dungeon with everyone else; the candlewax burns her hand. The candlelight burns her eyes– it’s so much brighter than you think it is, candlelight, when you’ve been in the pitch black for days.
The sunlight burns her eyes and burns and burns and burns. Gabriella squints and winces. She walks with her eyes practically shut. If not for those chains, dragging her, she’d never have been able to make her way to wherever they have her going. She keeps shuffling along straight, blind, whenever the rest of the group is turning this way or that way, down this or that street, and then suddenly, she’s yanked to the side. The jolt hurts her ribs. The jolt hurts her ruined elbow and her ruined fingers.
Obviously, they’re bringing her to the marketplace. Of course, they’re bringing her to the marketplace, and when Gabriella’s eyes have finally adjusted enough to realize that, she feels stupid for ever being confused. This is the marketplace that she’s marching into, now– this is where the prisoners march every day, and she’s a prisoner, and she’s marching. Why had it not occurred to her anywhere before this moment that this was where she was going?
Has she never been able to imagine herself here? The other prisoners have already started screaming out for mercy. They don’t have to, yet, really– not until they reach the far end of the marketplace square, where they will line up in their rows. The guards won’t start forcing them until there. But they are really screaming out for mercy, which is what they are doing, and maybe today will be the day that someone will hear them– it will all be too much– someone will come running out of the crowd to do something.
It’s not impossible, is it?-- it really isn’t. There was a whole protest last week, wasn’t there? There was, there was. Whatever happened with that? Gabriella is staring at the marketplace as she walks. Look at that table of fruit, where she’d been standing, up with her megaphone, shouting. Look at those carts that Immanuel and Aldonza overturned, back upright again– everything back to normal. Look at all these people here, who had been just standing and watching– and now they are standing, and watching. Look at her– here she is.
How could they be so stupid?-- bringing her back here– to exactly this same place– and expecting her to shut the fuck up? How could anyone be so stupid? She’s going to have an absolute fucking crash out– that’s what she’s going to do. She’s going to lose her fucking shit. They’ve brought her back; she’s going to make a new scene for them. It’s gonna be entirely not chill. She’s gonna make it awkward, she’s gonna make it cringe. They’re going to have to kill her– she’s going to make them kill her. That’s the only way they’re going to be able to shut her up– the arrogance of them! They thought they’d seen bad before?-- they thought they’d seen the worst she could do? Oh, fuck that. They don’t have the first fucking idea what she’s going to do. But it’s quiet, suddenly.
The sudden quiet pops right through the soap-film of Gabriella’s little story about herself; why is it so quiet, suddenly?
Everyone is staring at her. The prisoners have all come to their rows, and they’re all standing, now, together, and they are staring at her. Not shouting– they’ve stopped shouting where they were supposed to start. They’re silent– staring at Gabriella. The guards are staring at Gabriella. The crowd is staring at Gabriella.
The Mayor is staring at Gabriella, up at his podium. You could do some measurements– is his head at the same height as hers had been standing up on the table during the protest? Is this a little higher? Has he brought something to stand on? He hasn’t started his usual speech yet. He’s just staring at her.
He’s waiting. Everyone is waiting. The prisoners are waiting. The guards are waiting. The crowd is waiting. The Mayor is waiting. Everyone is waiting. In the faces, Gabriella can see Immanuel, standing. Immanuel is waiting.
Look at her. Here she is. Here she is. Here she is. Here she is, with her ruined arm, her ruined fingers; she is misshapen; she has been misshapen.
Two of the guards lower the narrow tips of their spears down from the sky– barely, they lower them. They are not an attack; they are a conversation. They are a tipped hand– “Go ahead, then.” Silence.
The spears come down a little further. They are starting to tilt towards Gabriella. “Where is your great howling speech, then? Where is your last hurrah? When are you making your stand? We’re all here. We’re all waiting.”
Everyone is waiting. Gabriella catches Immanuel’s eyes in the crowd, again. He is staring, staring at her. Nobody has ever stared at Gabriella in all her life the way he is staring at her, now. They haven’t gotten him yet. He’s come out today, never mind the danger, just to see her here. Does he still believe? One of the other prisoners– a man, in the other line– he starts back up at shouting for mercy– nothing is happening– he’s tired of waiting– but just as quickly, a guard steps forward and stops him with a hand on the shoulder– no. Not until she speaks. No. We’re all waiting. She’s going to speak her mind, and then we’re going to kill her, and then you can keep begging for mercy. We’re all waiting. Here she is. Look at her. Gabriella’s eyes drop to her feet. She starts to tell herself another little story about herself. She tells herself another little story.
“...I condemn Hamas,” she says, quietly, while she is telling her stories. “...hmmm?” says the Mayor.
Again, more loudly– nobody was able to hear her– “I condemn Hamas! I support Israel’s right to exist!” She glances at the Mayor, who is searching her eyes. He sees what he needs to see. He nods. He turns to the crowd. He begins his speech. The other prisoners– finally– they begin their usual cries, and the guards let them carry on. And carry on. And carry on.
Immanuel vanishes backwards into the crowd and away. He is so disappointed. She isn’t at all who he’d thought she was. He’d admired her so much. He’d followed her. He’d thought she’d never be one of those people who break– she’s pathetic, he realizes. They broke her so easily.
They’d never break him so easily. “Please!” cries Gabriella. “I take it all back! Please!” cries Gabriella, along with everyone else. “I repent!”














